The paper “Understanding, virtually: How does the synthetic cell matter?”, by Daphne Broeks, Tarja Knuuttila and Henk de Regt, is published in the journal Perspectives on Science, in a special issue on virtual entities in science. The paper results from Daphne’s PhD project on philosophical aspects of the synthetic cell.
Abstract: This paper examines how scientific understanding is enhanced by virtual entities, focusing on the case of the synthetic cell. Comparing it to other virtual entities and environments in science, we argue that the synthetic cell has a virtual dimension, in that it is functionally similar to living cells, though it does not mimic any particular naturally evolved cell (nor is it constructed to do so). In being cell-like at most, the synthetic cell is akin to many other virtual objects as it is selective and only partially implemented. However, there is one important difference: it is constructed by using the same materials and, to some extent, the same kind of processes as its natural counterparts. In contrast to virtual reality, especially to that of digital entities and environments, the details of its implementation is what matters for the scientific understanding generated by the synthetic cell. We conclude by arguing for the close connection between the virtual and the artifactual.