Aanslagen Twin Towers op 11 september 2001
Aanslagen Twin Towers op 11 september 2001

25 years after 11 September: ‘Strangely enough, this era is more peaceful than ever’

Theories about a ‘clash of civilisations’ did exist, but on 11 September 2001 those theories suddenly became reality. Twenty-five years on, one can therefore speak of a world before and a world after 9/11. That is the view of American studies scholar Peter van der Heiden. ‘At the very least, it has been the catalyst for a number of fundamental changes in the world.’

In early 2001, Peter van der Heiden travelled to America. He was able to board the plane in no time at all. ‘A few months later – and still today – you have to jump through all sorts of hoops just to check in.’ The same applies to the ESTA, which everyone travelling to the United States must apply for. ‘Before 9/11, you simply had to fill in a short form on board and you were allowed into the country.’

But the most far-reaching changes are the things we don’t immediately see, Van der Heiden emphasises. ‘CCTV surveillance and the enormous flow of information that government agencies and security services collect about us are a consequence of the 11 September attacks.’ Although attacks on American embassies had already taken place in previous years, such a large-scale attack on home soil, in which so many civilians were killed, was entirely new for the United States. ‘That had a massive impact on America, which had always considered itself invulnerable. Suddenly, everyone was a potential victim – and everyone became a potential perpetrator.’

Van der Heiden points to the rise in Islamophobia directly linked to 9/11. ‘You saw this in America, which began to present itself ever more emphatically as a Christian nation, but also in the Netherlands, where Pim Fortuyn was held up as a hero in the months following the attacks, whilst before that day he had been on course for just one or two seats with Leefbaar Nederland.’ And although that link is not always equally clear 25 years on, Van der Heiden believes there is certainly a connection between the 11 September attacks and political developments today. ‘Trump used that xenophobia to become president.’

Peter van der Heiden

Kept in the dark

Van der Heiden sees the clearest repercussions of 11 September in the Middle East. ‘Bush immediately seized on the attacks to invade Afghanistan and later to finish his father’s work in Iraq. The chaos they have caused in that region is immense. Without the war in Iraq, organisations such as IS would never have grown so large, if indeed they would have been founded at all.’

Initially, the world rallied firmly behind the United States, and many understood President Bush’s tough talk (‘we will smoke them out of their holes’) all too well. But that image would suffer a massive blow in the years that followed. ‘Ever since President Kennedy, America had presented itself as “the shining city on a hill”, but when it emerged that the country had pulled the wool over the world’s eyes with the invasion of Iraq – and it turned out there were no weapons of mass destruction there at all – America’s good reputation was all but ruined.’

And it is just as well that we no longer idolise America or regard it as a guiding light, argues Van der Heiden. ‘Whichever president is in office, from Obama to Trump, in essence the United States is a country that will do almost anything to maintain and expand its own power.’ As the legally illegal invasion of Iraq shows, they certainly do not allow themselves to be held back by international law. ‘It’s ironic, really, that the founder of the liberal legal order is now the one tearing it down again.’ 

No progress at all

A quarter of a century after 11 September 2001, the world seems to have made no progress at all. ‘In Afghanistan, the Taliban are back in power; Israel's actions in Palestine remain appalling; and Iran pays no heed to American bombings. Meanwhile, we await the emergence of new terrorist cells. When you look at it that way, things actually seem to be getting worse. And this is just a selection of all the violent conflicts currently underway.’

Yet, strangely enough, this is the most peaceful period in human history. In other words: statistically speaking, more people than ever are currently living in peace, and there has never been so little war. ‘That statistic is perhaps something we can hold on to amidst all the news about violent conflicts.’

Contact information

Theme
Current affairs, International, Politics