Stockfoto van een (huis)arts
Stockfoto van een (huis)arts

Cultural differences affect care for Turkish-Dutch patients

Dutch healthcare professionals have a different perspective on care than Turkish-Dutch patients, meaning that healthcare in the Netherlands does not always align with the needs of this group. This reduces trust in the Dutch healthcare system. This is demonstrated by research conducted by Iclal Yildiz, who will defend her PhD on this topic at Radboud University on 20 April.

Turkish-Dutch patients do not always feel taken seriously by Dutch doctors. This is evident from interviews conducted by Yildiz with Turkish-Dutch patients and Dutch healthcare professionals about mental health problems, the expression of emotions and the purpose of medical consultations. According to Yildiz, this is partly related to the healthcare system. “In the Netherlands, the general practitioner is the first point of contact for medical or psychological complaints. As a result, it can take relatively long before a diagnosis is made. In Türkiye, this works differently: people often go directly to a medical specialist and do not need to see a GP first,” Yildiz explains.

The fact that diagnoses are sometimes made late is partly related to how doctors are paid. In Türkiye, medical specialists are paid per diagnosis or treatment they provide: the more patients they treat, the more they are paid. In the Netherlands, doctors receive a payment per registered patient in addition to their salary, regardless of whether a patient seeks care. “Research shows that diagnoses tend to be made less quickly in countries where doctors are paid in this way,” says Yildiz. There are other differences as well: Dutch healthcare professionals often ask patients to contribute to decisions about their treatment plan. “Turkish-Dutch patients are often not used to this, based on their experiences in Türkiye. They tend to think: ‘you are the specialist, you know better than I do what is going on’,” Yildiz adds.

Because diagnoses are sometimes delayed or not made at all, Turkish-Dutch patients may live with symptoms for extended periods. In some cases, they turn to Turkish doctors, who are more likely to provide a diagnosis quickly. “When they return and consult a Dutch doctor, that diagnosis is often questioned. This reduces their trust in Dutch healthcare,” Yildiz explains.

Treatment of mental health problems

Turkish-Dutch patients and Dutch healthcare professionals also differ in their views on the treatment of mental health problems, such as depressive symptoms, and on receiving diagnostic labels such as ADHD. “Dutch treatment often does not align well with Turkish culture. In the Netherlands, much mental healthcare is focused on the individual: what can you do yourself to solve a problem?” Yildiz explains.

In the interviews, Yildiz found that it is not always easy for Turkish-Dutch patients to talk to the person with whom they have a problem. “Türkiye has a collectivist culture, where maintaining harmony is very important. For example, if you have a conflict with your in-laws and you confront them, you disrupt that harmony.” As a result, Turkish-Dutch patients may feel that the conversations and assignments suggested by Dutch healthcare professionals—such as confronting someone—cannot easily be applied in their daily lives. This can lead to treatment being discontinued prematurely and depressive symptoms persisting.

There are also differences in the expression of emotions. “The interviews show that Turkish-Dutch patients often experience emotions quite intensely, which can conflict with the approach of many Dutch healthcare professionals. These professionals tend to believe that, over time, patients should try to let go of intense emotions in order to move forward,” Yildiz says.

Awareness of cultural differences

Yildiz calls on healthcare professionals to be aware of cultural differences. Providing clear explanations about the differences between the Turkish and Dutch healthcare systems can help, so that patients understand that it may take longer to receive a diagnosis than they are used to in Türkiye.

In addition, healthcare professionals can adapt their approach to treatment based on these differences, for example when it comes to assigning diagnostic labels. “Within the Turkish community, there is often a stigma attached to certain labels given by healthcare professionals, which can discourage people from consulting a GP. Dutch healthcare professionals can help by describing symptoms and providing information, without necessarily assigning a formal label,” the researcher explains.

“If both sides are aware of these differences, they will understand each other better. This can help prevent Turkish-Dutch patients from living with untreated symptoms for longer than necessary.”

Contact information

For further information, please contact the researcher involved or team Science communication via +31 24 361 6000 or media [at] ru.nl (media[at]ru[dot]nl).

Organizational unit
Faculty of Social Sciences
Theme
Diversity, Society, Health & Healthcare