Twee mensen met mondkapje
Twee mensen met mondkapje

“Long COVID is not just a growing medical problem”

Being told that you are prolonging your illness with your own thoughts.
That is the bitter reality for many individuals suffering from Long COVID. Vivienne Matthies-Boon, Professor of Philosophical Ethics and Political Philosophy at Radboud University, is involved in international research to improve the ethical and socio-political situation for this growing group. “We need to prevent people with Long COVID from disappearing into the shadows of society.”

It is a huge contrast to five years ago. At the start of the COVID pandemic, people suddenly started to look out for each other much more. “There was a great sense of solidarity,” says Matthies-Boon. “Neighbours checked on each other, we took vulnerable people into account. But what often happens is that solidarity declines the longer a crisis lasts. As social support decreased, the Dutch government eventually opted for a COVID policy incorporating individual responsibility. And that created a politics of indifference and a breakdown of mutual understanding. Another consequence of choosing individual responsibility was that our government didn’t launch a campaign informing the public about Long COVID, despite much already being known about the medical effects at that time. That decision has perpetuated the lack of understanding for this condition.”

Matthies-Boon sees another reason for the distrust aimed at Long COVID patients. “The pandemic confronted us with the fragility of life. There was a group of people who didn’t want to face that fragility. They radicalised, particularly with respect to COVID sufferers. As a result, patients with Long COVID were increasingly regarded as being too fearful of the virus, making themselves ill with their own thoughts.” This psychologisation of post-viral diseases is not new, says Matthies-Boon. “Since the 1970s and 1980s, it has been increasingly claimed that people are pretending to be ill and that it is important to rid them of these false illusions. However, that view completely overlooks the objective immunological processes involved in both Long COVID and other post-acute infection syndromes.”

Foto van Vivienne Matthies-Boon

Risk of invisibility

People with Long COVID therefore face many ethical and socio-political implications, Matthies-Boon explains. “Medical ethics is not just about the interaction between the patient and the doctor, but especially about the patient's interaction with people around them. That interaction has an impact on how Long COVID is generally viewed. Which in turn has a socio-political impact. Take the opening of the Long COVID clinics. In the Netherlands, not every patient can access them, unlike similar clinics in Germany, which also have extremely long waiting lists. Many Long COVID patients have little energy, some are even bed-bound. They are therefore unable to go out campaigning to draw attention to the need to improve their rights. As such, they risk becoming invisible to the outside world. We need to prevent people with Long COVID from disappearing into the shadows of society.

Matthies-Boon emphasises that the stakes are high for Long COVID patients. “They are now excluded from society because they can’t risk getting infected again. Any reinfection increases the risk of all the long-term effects of Long COVID. So it would help them if wearing face masks was normalised in certain public places. Many Long COVID patients still experience social aggression when they wear a mask for their own protection. And it is particularly tough for children who have Long COVID. They become isolated, fall behind in their education and make few if any friendships. Their rights to education and social development are violated because there are no safe alternative parallel structures for them. Ideally, there should be one COVID-safe school in every province, where PCR testing is carried out and face masks - for those who need them - are normalised. And where air is ventilated and rest areas are provided. Long COVID is not just a growing medical problem, but also a social and political issue.” 

Embracing the fragility of life

To improve the ethical and socio-political situation of Long COVID patients, the universities of Leipzig, Zurich, Glasgow and Radboud University are collaborating. With her involvement in this international research, Matthies-Boon hopes to achieve three goals. “Firstly, we hope to find a way to stop the psychologisation - and thus misunderstanding - of Long COVID. In addition, we want to achieve political urgency for Long COVID. Finally, the aim is to gain recognition from politicians in general for the severity of post-viral chronicity, which will only increase with climate change. Global warming also increases the risk of various infectious diseases on our continent. Like malaria, mosquito fever and chronic Lyme disease caused by ticks. We hope to draw more attention to this with policy papers and academic articles.”

Matthies-Boon argues for a revolution from a philosophical perspective. “The COVID pandemic and post-viral chronicity due to climate change prove that we need to move away from autonomous, individualistic thinking. Instead, we should embrace the fragility of life more. This means acknowledging that you are part of a social, cultural environment. This will bring us closer to joint responsibility, with more understanding for each other.”

Photo: Julian Wan via Unsplash

Contact information

Theme
Ethics, Philosophy, Health & Healthcare