Some did not even know there was a place called ‘Holland’. Others who did know were just as surprised. The country to which they normally sold their surplus grain was now sending them food for free? The grateful Poles, timber merchant Jan Wagenaar wrote, regarded it as a ‘Miracle of Heavenly Providence’. They would pray for blessings upon those noble Hollanders. Yes, for those ‘angels’ who had saved them from starvation.
On the night of 20 to 21 January 1737, the region around the Polish port city of Gdańsk (Danzig) was flooded. That alone was already disastrous, but the floodwaters also destroyed the fertile farmland. The flood was followed by famine. Wagenaar decided, together with a few fellow merchants, to launch a relief campaign. But how do you persuade potential donors to give money to people far away? He found the answer in the body, and in the soul.
Not just for one church
If ‘no prompt assistance arrived’, Wagenaar warned, the Poles would ‘have to kill their own children, because they could no longer bear to hear their crying and lamentation’. He wrote this in an appeal to the inhabitants of Dutch towns, asking them to donate money for food aid. The collection was unusual. Not because funds were being raised for people in need abroad. Collections for victims beyond the Republic’s borders were quite common. Yet those victims always belonged to a particular religious denomination. Calvinists, for example, raised money for their persecuted brothers and sisters in Germany and France. Wagenaar, however, took a different approach.
‘The distress’, Wagenaar wrote, ‘afflicts all denominations, without distinction.’ Worse still, it was precisely the unpopular Roman Catholics and Lutherans who received the least assistance, despite being in the most miserable circumstances. Something had to be done. Together with several unnamed fellow merchants, Wagenaar organised a relief campaign for all victims, regardless of their religious convictions. In the end, the collection raised more than 15,000 guilders.
A collegiant collection
Wagenaar’s mission cannot be separated from his own faith. He was a Collegiant, and his fellow organisers probably were as well. The Collegiant movement was a small, radical offshoot of the Remonstrants. Its members wanted nothing to do with ecclesiastical hierarchies or doctrinal disputes. Instead, they saw themselves as members of an inclusive, ‘universal church’. Within the Dutch Republic, they collected money for all poor people, not only fellow Collegiants. And after the flooding around Gdańsk, they even raised money for all victims in a distant foreign land.
As contemporary research into charitable giving shows, people prefer donating to groups with whom they identify. A shared national identity, for instance, is often a good reason to open one’s wallet. The same applies to a shared religious identity. In the eighteenth century, the latter was especially important. Charity generally took place within religious communities. Wagenaar wanted to break with that tradition.
The shared body
Wagenaar needed to convince his Dutch readers that they nonetheless shared something with this interfaith group of victims living so far away. What was that? The body. Wagenaar described how the Polish victims had to mistreat their own bodies in order to survive. ‘Many greedily consume the most dreadful foodstuffs,’ he wrote, before listing these inedible provisions: ‘the flesh of drowned animals’, boiled hay, and ‘swill [pig feed] mixed with ox blood’.
This emphasis on the suffering body fitted within what the historian Thomas Laqueur called the humanitarian narrative. Laqueur identified a strong interest in bodily suffering in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century novels, and in printed autopsy reports. This was not simply a matter of sensationalism, or at least not entirely. The descriptions of pain were meant to evoke empathy. Human flesh, Laqueur wrote in The New Cultural History (1989), was ‘the bond between those who suffer and those who can help’. Alongside these detailed depictions of pain, writers also explained what readers could do to assist the victims.
The humanitarian narrative appeared in eighteenth-century descriptions of disasters. In the nineteenth century, Dutch writers and poets became even more adept at using it, as Fons Meijer demonstrated in his dissertation Verbonden door rampspoed (2023). Anyone paying attention will still recognise elements of the humanitarian narrative in contemporary appeals by aid organisations.
Interest in heaven
Wagenaar also employed one argument that is less likely to appear in modern fundraising appeals: heavenly interest. This was the idea that gifts made during one’s lifetime would be rewarded by God after one’s death. It was a popular argument used by ministers and priests to persuade their congregations to support charitable causes. Wagenaar thus employed a common rhetorical trick.
He quoted a passage from the Gospel of Luke (12:33), in which Jesus instructs his followers to store up treasure in heaven rather than on Earth. ‘Such work never goes unrewarded,’ Wagenaar wrote, because the ‘God of mercy ... will never forget the labour of love’. Better still, those grateful Poles would continue reminding Him through their prayers.