Shadow of black hole M87* is wobblingShadow of black hole M87* is wobbling

The EHT team that published the first images of the shadow of a black hole last year used the knowledge they gained to analyse archive data from the period 2009-2013 and concluded that the shadow has been wobbling across the years. The findings of the team, which includes PhD students Sara Issaoun and Christiaan Brinkerink from Radboud University, and Sera Markoff and her PhD student Koushik Chatterjee from the University of Amsterdam, were published today in The Astrophysical Journal.

The EHT (Event Horizon Telescope) is an array of telescopes that uses the very-long-baseline interferometry (VLBI) technique to form a virtual radio telescope with a dish diameter the size of the Earth. Between 2009 and 2013, M87* (the supermassive black hole at the centre of the M87 galaxy) was observed using prototype EHT arrays; from three locations in 2009-2012 and four in 2013. The full EHT array became operational in 2017, at which time it consisted of seven telescopes at five locations around the globe.

Although the observations dating from 2009-2013 contain much fewer data than those from 2017, which impeded the creation of images at the time, the EHT team was able to use statistical models to find changes in the appearance of M87* between 2009 and 2017.


De schaduw van het zwarte gat M87* wiebelt

Snapshots of the appearance of M87*, obtained using measurements and geometric models and the EHT array between 2009 and 2017. The diameter of the rings remains unchanged, but the position of the bright side varies. Credit: M. Wielgus, D. Pesce & the EHT Collaboration.

They concluded that the diameter of the shadow of the black hole remains consistent with the predictions for black holes of 6.5 billion solar masses based on Einstein’s general theory of relativity. However, they also made an unexpected discovery: the crescent-shaped ring of hot plasma around M87* wiggles. As such, the astronomers have caught the first glimpse of a dynamic accretion structure this close to the event horizon of a black hole, where gravity is extremely high.

Sara Issaoun (Radboud University): “We applied the knowledge we gained during the previous observations of M87* in 2017 on older data. We discovered that the size of the ring remained unchanged, but the radiation of the gas around it changes over the years.”

To this, Sera Markoff (UvA) adds: “The brightness of a given point in the ring depends on the properties of the gas around the black hole as well as on its ‘spin’ and their relative orientations. We have already been able to rule out several theoretical models of accretion, which allows us to better test the laws of gravity around black holes.”

The EHT astronomers now dispose of a wealth of data on the dynamics of black holes. The team is currently analysing the data from 2018 that involved an additional telescope in Greenland. The array will be further expanded with two additional telescopes in 2021.


The scientists in Amsterdam and Nijmegen are members of the BlackHoleCam research group. This project received a 14-million-euro Synergy Grant from the European Research Council in 2013. Heino Falcke (Radboud University) is the Principal Investigator, together with co-PIs Luciano Rezzolla (Goethe University Frankfurt) and Michael Kramer (Max-Planck Institute Bonn). The partner institutes in BlackHoleCam are JIVE, IRAM, MPE Garching, IRA/INAF Bologna, SKA and ESO. BlackHoleCam is part of the EHT.

Press release: NOVA


Monitoring the Morphology of M87* in 2009–2017 with the Event Horizon Telescope
DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/abac0d

More information? Please contact: