In the café where the interview takes place, there is just one sunny spot. Someone is sitting there, enjoying the autumn sunshine, turning her face directly towards the single ray of sunlight.
Death is the most personal thing there is, but how do you deal with it professionally?
Philosopher and narratologist Linde van Schuppen, together with Professor Enny Das, delved into the fascinations, questions and notes left behind by their colleague Judith Peters, who died in 2022. Judith was fascinated by extraordinary experiences of grief and our continuing bonds with the deceased, but also by the inner lives of doctors who confront death in their professional lives every day. Van Schuppen: “The project has left me a different person from who I was when I started.”
The sunlight falling on that one table immediately reminds Van Schuppen of Judith. “Judith's father died when she was nineteen. A few years later, when she visited his grave on a cloudy day, a ray of sunlight shone directly onto it. Nowhere else in the cemetery. She described how this experience made her feel that her father was close to her and always would be. The end of a life doesn't necessarily mean the end of a relationship with that person.”
As a scholar of language and communication, Judith was fascinated by how we deal with death and the enduring bond between the deceased and those they leave behind. For her research project Stories of Loss, she collected accounts of extraordinary experiences of grief in which people felt a sense of contact or connection with someone who had died.
Take over a research project
Van Schuppen took over this research project from her colleague Judith. Although she had not known Judith personally, she decided to respond to a call from Professor Enny Das to continue her late colleague's research. Van Schuppen: “I sometimes saw Judith walking through the corridors of the Erasmus Building. Unfortunately, I never got to know her.”
Judith was diagnosed with neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2), a rare condition, at the age of 25, leading to a difficult course of medical treatment. Despite this, she continued working determinedly on the stories of extraordinary grief experiences she had collected. These were brought together in the 2021 book Ze kwamen nog één keer terug (They Came Back One Last Time).
Meanwhile, Judith received further bad news from her doctors about her health. As a result, she was unable to complete her doctoral dissertation under the supervision of Professor Enny Das. Das and Van Schuppen completed Judith's research into these stories and published the findings.
Symbol
Judith wanted to understand more about how people experience grief and how extraordinary experiences of connection with someone who has died can offer comfort. Symbols often play an important role in such experiences, Van Schuppen explains.
“For example, butterflies have traditionally been associated with the immortal soul or life after death, and they frequently appeared in the stories Judith collected. But hearing ‘your’ song on the radio can also feel as though the deceased person is briefly with you again, sending you a sign. Or a rainbow appearing at a meaningful moment.
“Sometimes people also feel supported. One person, for instance, described how the lights suddenly went out at a moment when she was feeling completely overwhelmed and uncertain about a decision. It made her feel that her late mother was with her, offering guidance.”
An active voice
Two years after Judith's death, Van Schuppen met with two people who had known her very well: her partner Arjan and a female friend.
“I wanted to understand Judith's interests so I could get a sense of how she would have wanted to complete her research project. I'm not Judith, and I can only do it in my own way, but I wanted to do justice to what mattered to her.”
Alongside her research into experiences of grief, Judith had also become interested, during her illness, in the inner lives of her doctors and their relationships with patients. She had conceived the idea of an interview project with doctors, asking what it was actually like for them to have to tell someone they might die, or to hold someone's life in their hands during surgery.
Arjan found Judith's notes for this interview project and passed them on to Van Schuppen.
Van Schuppen: “Using her notes as a guide, Enny and I carried out an adapted version of the interview project. By incorporating her notes, we were able to give Judith a genuinely active voice in the research.
“I read that Judith had been inspired by a book by neurosurgeon Henry Marsh in which he writes about his work. That work raises ethical questions: how do you decide whether to continue treating someone when the prognosis is poor, but the patient desperately wants to go on? Do you offer someone hope during a medical consultation when their chances of survival are slim?”
Van Schuppen sums it up in a single sentence: “Death is the most personal thing there is, but how do you deal with it professionally?”
Talking about death
In addition to interviewing doctors, Van Schuppen chose to interview three writers, thinkers and artists about how we try to make sense of death, both culturally and personally, within medicine and beyond. These interviews are being published on the website Bij Nader Inzien.
Van Schuppen: “All the interviewees approach these subjects from different perspectives. The conversations explore the roles of ritual, rhythm, religion, art, culture, social dynamics and social criticism, but above all, how we relate to the inevitable.”
Judith is not the only woman who died young to have contributed to the project. Poet Lieke Marsman, who died in June, was a close friend of Van Schuppen.
Lieke wrote and spoke about many of the same subjects that interested Judith. Van Schuppen: “In her book Op een andere planeet kunnen ze me redden (On Another Planet They Can Save Me), Lieke searches for a meaningful way of relating to her own illness and mortality.
“Her critical, poetic and intelligent approach had a profound influence on the questions I asked and the answers I found interesting. In that sense, Lieke was always there at the table with me during the conversations I had.”
The paper Judith began, which Van Schuppen and Das completed together, was recently published in Death Studies, with Judith listed as the second author.
Through this academic publication and the interview series on Bij Nader Inzien, Van Schuppen hopes the research will contribute to a more compassionate and meaningful way of thinking about grief and death.
“Ultimately, death is something we will all have to face. We will all lose people, and we will all die ourselves. How should we talk and think about death? Do we have sufficient social and societal structures to enable us to look into that abyss? And above all, what can we learn from others?
“What Judith, Lieke and this research have taught me is that it's important to keep an open mind when thinking about death: embrace the ‘maybe’ and find ways to give shape to the fundamental uncertainty of life.”
Judith Peters Fund
Linde van Schuppen was able to continue Judith's work thanks to a contribution from the Judith Peters Fund, part of the Radboud Fund.
Contact information
- Organizational unit
- Faculty of Arts, Centre for Language Studies
- Theme
- Ethics, Philosophy, Language, Health & Healthcare